Find and Contact Local Insurance Agent | Madison WI | Baer Insurance Services

Skip to content

Facebook-f X-twitter Linkedin Envelope

Claims & Bill Pay
Client Services
Zywave Login
Mineral Login
CondoInsuranceNow
Call (608) 830-5800
Toll Free (888) 729-2237

About
Service
Personal Insurance
PERSONAL INSURANCE

As an independent insurance agency we offer a full-range of Personal Lines Insurance plans from a multitude of insurance companies. Our commitment to your specific needs means you will always receive professional and personalized local attention, at your convenience.

Get A Personal Insurance Quote

Auto

Today's modern technology filled vehicles can be a very costly investment for just about everyone, one that is exposed to many potential losses that are out of your control. We’ll help you obtain the protection you need at a very affordable price.

Learn More

Home

Your home is most likely your largest asset. That’s why it’s so important to do everything you can to protect it. We’re here to help you plan for the unexpected with insurance coverage that’s right for your home and your family.

Learn More

Life

Although we can’t put a dollar amount on our family's future, we can ensure that our intended financial contributions are protected. No one can predict when the unexpected will happen, but we can help you prepare for it when it does.

Learn More

More Selections

Motorcyle Insurance

Senior Drivers Insurance

High Value Home Insurance

Liability Umbrella

Flood Insurance

Earthquake Insurance

Personal Overview
Commercial Insurance
COMMERCIAL INSURANCE

A Business Owners Policy (BOP) easily combines business property and business liability insurance into one convenient policy. We’re here to work with you and design the right combination of additional coverages to protect your business from a variety of challenging risks within your industry.

Get A Commercial Insurance Quote

Comm Auto

Whether you have one vehicle or an entire fleet, we can help you in obtaining the custom coverages that will provide greater protection for your business and personal assets from the increased exposure commercial vehicles bring.

Learn More

Property

Coverage for general risks associated with your business’ premises, equipment and vehicles. It can often include associated loss of business which is essential since it ensures your assets, business, and income are protected.

Learn More

Liability

No matter the shape, size and nature of your business, there are always uncertainties looming just around the corner. We’ll work with you and discuss your business risks and offer an insurance package that makes solid sense for you.

Learn More

More Selections

Condominium Association Insurance

Group Benefits

Workers’ Compensation

Inland Marine Insurance

Excess Liability

Cyber Liability – Data Breach

Management Liability

Contractors Insurance

Metalworking Operations

Restaurants Insurance

Liquor Liability Insurance

Salons & Barbers Insurance

Apartment Owners Insurance

Commercial Overview
Group Benefits
GROUP BENEFITS

At Baer Insurance Services our unique approach to service distinguishes us from others in our industry. Not only does it take a large commitment, but requires great consistency. Consistency refers to meeting with clients on a regular basis and forging partnerships typically unseen.

We are not the “cookie cutter” agency who delivers the renewal pricing and visits you on a relatively infrequent basis. Likewise, our approach requires that our clients display a deep desire to involve themselves in the program. In concert with you, we will control loss experience, manage employee’s health and wellness and positively influence future premiums.

Areas of Assistance

Regardless of your plan and carrier selection we will assist in the following areas:

Plan Design

Program Implementation

Orientations

Employee Communication

Enrollment

Account Reconciliation

Single Point Billing if Desired

Health and Wellness Education

Carrier Communication

Employee/Carrier Intervention

Products & Services

Group Medical

Group Disability (Long & Short Term)

Group Life

Group Dental

Group Vision

Employee Assistance Services

Group Long Term Care

Prepaid Legal Services

Human Resource Consulting

Payroll Administration

Single Point Billing & Acct Reconciliation

Health & Wellness Programs

Supplemental (Payroll Deduction)

Employee Leasing

401-K

Cafeteria Plans

Health Savings Accounts

Self Insured Plans

Measured Results

Results will be measured as we deliver:

Greater Employee Participation

Improved Employee Morale

Enhanced Communication

Better Claims Experience

Premium Increase Control

Reduced Employer Administrative

Obligations

Heightened Awareness of Health and Wellness
Contact

About
Insurance
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Group Benefits
Service
Insurance Quotes
Secure Services
News
Contact

About
Insurance
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Group Benefits
Service
Insurance Quotes
Secure Services
News
Contact

PERSONAL

COMMERCIAL

CONTACT

GET QUOTE

Baer Insurance Services

Contact Us

Baer Insurance Services

9701 Brader Way, Suite 101
Middleton, WI 53562

Tel: (608) 830-5800
Toll Free: (888) 729-2237
Fax: (608) 830-5877
Email: Send Email

Office Hours: M-F 8:00am to 4:30pm

Mailing Address:
Baer Insurance Services
P.O. Box 46490
Madison, WI 53744

Get Insurance Quote

Communicate With Us

We would love to hear from you! Please complete this simple form and we will get in touch with you soon.
Identify Your Need or Request*
- Question
- Request For Service
- Insurance Quote Request
- Comment
- Other

Your Contact Info
Name*
First Last
Email Address*
Enter Email Confirm Email
Phone*
Phone Type*
- Cell
- Work
- Home
- Other
COMMUNICATION INFO
Are You Currently A Client*
- Yes
- No
Subject*
Your Message*
Form Security
Email
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Our Team of Insurance

Professionals

Our focus is to help you make an informed decision about the coverage and policy options you have to be confident in your level of protection and pleased with the process.

Administration

Keith Kaetterhenry

Keith Kaetterhenry

CEO

608-830-5810

Patrick Kelly

Patrick Kelly

President

608-830-5834

Jonathon Zwettler

Jonathon Zwettler

Vice President of Sales

608-830-5808

Kristin Oster

Kristin Oster

Human Resources / Office Manager

608-830-5820

Commercial Lines

Stan Heller

Senior Account Executive

608-830-5802

Ryan Burns

Ryan Burns

Senior Account Executive
Municipalities

608-830-5833

Hillary Pink Budworth

Hillary Pink-Budworth

Senior Account Executive

608-830-5851

Brendan Woods

Brendan Woods

Account Executive

608-830-5837

Joey Broms

Account Executive

608-830-5848

Mike Sergeant

Mike Sergeant

Account Executive

608-830-5826

Sheila Blum

Sheila Blum

Account Manager
Epic Systems Specialist

608-830-5805

Nikki Huseth

Nikki Huseth

Account Manager

608-830-5804

Megan Corace

Megan Corace

Account Manager

608-830-5821

Jess Piontek

Jess Sorenson

Account Manager

608-830-5831

Samantha Carroll

Samantha Carroll

Account Manager

608-830-5829

Christina Karls

Christina Karls

Account Manager

608-830-5819

Mary Jo Nowak

Account Manager

608-830-5811

Cary Ness

Cary Neess

Small Business Specialist

608-830-5817

Padee Thor

Padee Thor

Small Business Specialist

608-830-5827

Michael Ingalls

Small Business Specialist

608-830-5809

Brian Kaetterhenry

Brian Kaetterhenry

Marketing Center Specialist

608-830-5824

Personal Lines

Melanie Penshorn

Melanie Penshorn

Senior Account Executive

608-830-5816

Jennie Owens

Jennie Owens

Account Executive

608-830-5807

Julie Smith

Julie Smith

Account Executive

608-830-5825

Erich Froemming

Erich Froemming

Account Executive

608-830-5835

Leah Sinner

Leah Sinner

Account Executive

608-830-5815

Employee Benefits

Lars Schultz

Benefits Account Executive

608-830-5850

Matt Busse

Matt Busse

Benefits Account Executive

608-830-5836

Pam Higinbotham

Account Manager

608-830-5823

Life Insurance

Whitney Biddick

Whitney Biddick

Account Executive

608-830-5814

Support

Kimberly Shea

Kimberly Shea

Digital/Media Specialist

608-830-5818

Beverly Petrolis

Receptionist

608-830-5800

Helen Kitelinger

P & C Admin Assistant

608-830-5822

Geoffrey Montgomery

Geoffrey Montgomery

Admin Assistant

608-830-5832

Maggie Edge

Maggie Rothmann

Project Specialist

608-830-5806

Kelly Deneen

Kelly Deneen

Associate Account Manager

608-830-5828

Kerington Sauser

Associate Account Manager

608-830-5803

Middleton, WI

Location

Visit Us

Baer Insurance Services

9701 Brader Way, Suite 101

Middleton, WI 53562

Map Us

Contact Us

M-F 8:00am to 4:30pm
(608) 830-5800
(888) 729-2237
(608) 830-5877
Send Email
Team Directory

GET STARTED

Get Insurance Quote
Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Insurance Companies
CondoInsuranceNow.com
Contact Us

Client Tools

CLIENT LOGIN
ZYWAVE LOGIN
MINERAL LOGIN
Secure Online Services
Refer A Friend
Claims & Bill Payments
News & Articles
Online Calculators

Licensed insurance agency in Wisconsin, Illinois and several other states across the country

Insurance coverage cannot be bound or changed via submission of any online form/application provided on this site. No binder, insurance policy, change, addition, and/or deletion to insurance coverage goes into effect unless and until confirmed directly by a licensed agent.

Connect With Us

Facebook-f X-twitter Linkedin

© 2025 All rights reserved

Privacy Policy Statement